Right from when I was 11 years old, my parents voices would echo in my ear. Repeating the phrase 'We just want you to be happy'. It would always puzzle me, because it would always be said in times when I was far from happy. The times when we had yelled at each other till my voice was hoarse and there were tears leaking from my eyes. I would ask myself, if you wanted me to be happy, how did you let it get this far?
And that is when I first started to question the inner motives of parents. Subconscious or otherwise. You see, my parents would appear to be the so called 'liberals' of their generation. Especially of the Asian community. I've often felt incredibly lucky that unlike some of my peers, my parents have never outright forced me into a career path. Never overtly planned my future.
This was something I always felt so incredibly proud of. Of their characters and humility. Their respect for me as an individual and my choices. My views on this began to change in the late parts of Year 10 when I was 15 years old.
I've mentioned before that English has always been an ardent love of mine (hence this blog) , and at this point in my life, I had decided it was something I would like to pursue at university. I knew I was still young, I knew I was still open to changing my mind, but it was my current choice - and honestly speaking... it was a relief. Despite being so young (I can understand that now with hindsight) I had so many panicked late nights, with the question 'what am I going to do with my life?' etched into every inch of my brain, and this decision was one that came with a sense of satisfaction and tranquillity.
I had done my research. With the dream of pursuing a career of journalism still freshly glittering in my thoughts, I made sure to properly look into the typical paths of those who had been successful before me. When I told my parents, I thought they would have shared my relief. Especially, with their previous declarations of letting me choose whichever path I wanted, which ever path would make me happy , I was certain that they would be pleased. They weren't. I was badgered with questions and skepticism.
On one hand, I can understand the parental reasoning behind this. Parents will understandably want to know that their child has fully thought a decision - that is so significant - through. Yet, despite making it clear that I had done my research and that I was aware of the competition, but pursuing a degree in English was what I really wanted to do, they still appeared hesitant.
Now, I know that ultimately if I had wanted to go through with getting an English degree, they would have let me. But what unsettles me is that I don't think they would have been as encouraging and supportive as they had otherwise lead me to believe. I just knew that they would be holding on to the 'I told you so(s)' for the future, when I would inevitably hit a minor bump in the road. And sometimes, I think the knowledge of that was a factor in making me re-evaluate my choice.
Yet, I won't blame them entirely. That wouldn't be fair. Ultimately, as a bit of a people pleaser, I wanted my parents to be fully on board with my choice of career but I was also determined to truly follow the path that I wanted to lead. Nevertheless, by chance, I began to research and explore the opportunities that could come with a Law degree - and the difference in their reactions was astonishing. Apart from the courtesy questions to check whether I was 'absolutely sure that this is was [I] wanted to do' , my parents didn't need much convincing. Certainly not as much as they needed for English.
And perhaps you might think that I am being unfair to them. That I am twisting the scenario to make them appear villainous, but let me assure you. I was on the receiving end of both of their reactions. I could tell the difference as if it were the back of my hand.
But I was happy. I was happy that I was finally getting the support and - arguably - their respect for my choice of degree and I have not looked back since. With more research and exploration into the subject, I have genuinely found a huge point of interest in the study of the Law and am thoroughly excited to eventually study it further. However, the disparity of their reactions remained unsettling to me, and thought I never vocalised my thoughts, I made an internal acknowledgement that perhaps my parents vehement declarations weren't as noble or liberal as they deceptively seemed.
You see, it became apparent to me that my parents' 'wish for me to be happy' actually meant that they wanted me to be happy on their terms. When I became increasingly aware of this, I began to more strongly believe in the idea that parents can subconsciously be quite selfish, in regards to the upbringing and future of their child, and after discussing with my parents - about this matter - profusely, my view has only been confirmed by their responses.
Let me put it this way. It almost as if I have been told that I have an endless amount of options to choose from, when in actual fact - I can choose anything I want - from the options that my parents have given me.
When discussing with my parents I asked them this ' If I was to come to you tomorrow and tell you that the only way I could ever be happy was if I was to become a hairdresser [ disclaimer : I have absolutely nothing against hairdressers and I would hate for this to come across snobby or anything like that. I only used it as an example because I knew it would be something that my parents would respond to] , would you be happy with me pursuing that?'
It took a lot of skilful, yet painfully frustrating evasions of my question to finally get my father to admit 'No, I would not be happy'. His reason ? Because I would supposedly not be independent or have a 'good standard of living'. I was appalled. My issue with my father's answer is layered. First and foremost, if we are to tackle the idea of happiness , I would have to counter his argument by stating that if, as a parent, his (as he has proclaimed himself) his sole aim is for me to be 'happy', why should he be unhappy if I achieve my happiness by being a hairdresser ? Why should the circumstances that lead to my happiness affect how he views the achievement of his supposed ultimate goal?
Unless that wasn't really his ultimate goal. His ultimate goal was - in reality - for me to be happy on his terms, by leading a life that he would be happy with. I won't dispute that if I was to become a hairdresser, I would not earn as much as him and I would perhaps not have the same lifestyle as he does, but if I had a job and could support myself and was happy - why should he , in theory, have an issue with that?
Moving away from the blatant disregard of the dignity of labour (that made me angry in itself, but that is another issue) , I was frustrated by his constant insistence that parents still just wanted ultimate happiness for their children. Some parents do, but most hide behind the phrase to conceal it.
And I guess, one might say, why shouldn't parents want that for their children? They provide for them, raise them - should they not be entitled to influence the life their child should lead ? My answer to that is no.
If two people decide that they want to take on the responsibility of parenthood, then they must also readily accept that their child will be their own person. It is a parent's responsibility to care and provide for their child till they are of age, and no child owes their parents the right to make major decisions about their life, in exchange for that.
Now, however scathing this post may appear to be in regards to parenthood and particularly my own parents, I want to assure you all that I am not some crazed parent hater. I understand and can empathise with the plight that parents can face. Indeed, putting myself in the position of a parent makes me wholly appreciate the difficulty in giving your child free reign over their lives, with the worry that they could really 'make a mess' of it and end up in serious trouble. Yet, there comes a point when the decisions of your child are no longer yours to make. And even though a child legally becomes an adult at the age of 18, they should be treated with the dignity and respect of one well before that. Their decisions should be respected and acknowledged as their own desires and wishes, not versions of your own (as parents).
And that is when I first started to question the inner motives of parents. Subconscious or otherwise. You see, my parents would appear to be the so called 'liberals' of their generation. Especially of the Asian community. I've often felt incredibly lucky that unlike some of my peers, my parents have never outright forced me into a career path. Never overtly planned my future.
This was something I always felt so incredibly proud of. Of their characters and humility. Their respect for me as an individual and my choices. My views on this began to change in the late parts of Year 10 when I was 15 years old.
I've mentioned before that English has always been an ardent love of mine (hence this blog) , and at this point in my life, I had decided it was something I would like to pursue at university. I knew I was still young, I knew I was still open to changing my mind, but it was my current choice - and honestly speaking... it was a relief. Despite being so young (I can understand that now with hindsight) I had so many panicked late nights, with the question 'what am I going to do with my life?' etched into every inch of my brain, and this decision was one that came with a sense of satisfaction and tranquillity.
I had done my research. With the dream of pursuing a career of journalism still freshly glittering in my thoughts, I made sure to properly look into the typical paths of those who had been successful before me. When I told my parents, I thought they would have shared my relief. Especially, with their previous declarations of letting me choose whichever path I wanted, which ever path would make me happy , I was certain that they would be pleased. They weren't. I was badgered with questions and skepticism.
On one hand, I can understand the parental reasoning behind this. Parents will understandably want to know that their child has fully thought a decision - that is so significant - through. Yet, despite making it clear that I had done my research and that I was aware of the competition, but pursuing a degree in English was what I really wanted to do, they still appeared hesitant.
Now, I know that ultimately if I had wanted to go through with getting an English degree, they would have let me. But what unsettles me is that I don't think they would have been as encouraging and supportive as they had otherwise lead me to believe. I just knew that they would be holding on to the 'I told you so(s)' for the future, when I would inevitably hit a minor bump in the road. And sometimes, I think the knowledge of that was a factor in making me re-evaluate my choice.
Yet, I won't blame them entirely. That wouldn't be fair. Ultimately, as a bit of a people pleaser, I wanted my parents to be fully on board with my choice of career but I was also determined to truly follow the path that I wanted to lead. Nevertheless, by chance, I began to research and explore the opportunities that could come with a Law degree - and the difference in their reactions was astonishing. Apart from the courtesy questions to check whether I was 'absolutely sure that this is was [I] wanted to do' , my parents didn't need much convincing. Certainly not as much as they needed for English.
And perhaps you might think that I am being unfair to them. That I am twisting the scenario to make them appear villainous, but let me assure you. I was on the receiving end of both of their reactions. I could tell the difference as if it were the back of my hand.
But I was happy. I was happy that I was finally getting the support and - arguably - their respect for my choice of degree and I have not looked back since. With more research and exploration into the subject, I have genuinely found a huge point of interest in the study of the Law and am thoroughly excited to eventually study it further. However, the disparity of their reactions remained unsettling to me, and thought I never vocalised my thoughts, I made an internal acknowledgement that perhaps my parents vehement declarations weren't as noble or liberal as they deceptively seemed.
You see, it became apparent to me that my parents' 'wish for me to be happy' actually meant that they wanted me to be happy on their terms. When I became increasingly aware of this, I began to more strongly believe in the idea that parents can subconsciously be quite selfish, in regards to the upbringing and future of their child, and after discussing with my parents - about this matter - profusely, my view has only been confirmed by their responses.
Let me put it this way. It almost as if I have been told that I have an endless amount of options to choose from, when in actual fact - I can choose anything I want - from the options that my parents have given me.
When discussing with my parents I asked them this ' If I was to come to you tomorrow and tell you that the only way I could ever be happy was if I was to become a hairdresser [ disclaimer : I have absolutely nothing against hairdressers and I would hate for this to come across snobby or anything like that. I only used it as an example because I knew it would be something that my parents would respond to] , would you be happy with me pursuing that?'
It took a lot of skilful, yet painfully frustrating evasions of my question to finally get my father to admit 'No, I would not be happy'. His reason ? Because I would supposedly not be independent or have a 'good standard of living'. I was appalled. My issue with my father's answer is layered. First and foremost, if we are to tackle the idea of happiness , I would have to counter his argument by stating that if, as a parent, his (as he has proclaimed himself) his sole aim is for me to be 'happy', why should he be unhappy if I achieve my happiness by being a hairdresser ? Why should the circumstances that lead to my happiness affect how he views the achievement of his supposed ultimate goal?
Unless that wasn't really his ultimate goal. His ultimate goal was - in reality - for me to be happy on his terms, by leading a life that he would be happy with. I won't dispute that if I was to become a hairdresser, I would not earn as much as him and I would perhaps not have the same lifestyle as he does, but if I had a job and could support myself and was happy - why should he , in theory, have an issue with that?
Moving away from the blatant disregard of the dignity of labour (that made me angry in itself, but that is another issue) , I was frustrated by his constant insistence that parents still just wanted ultimate happiness for their children. Some parents do, but most hide behind the phrase to conceal it.
And I guess, one might say, why shouldn't parents want that for their children? They provide for them, raise them - should they not be entitled to influence the life their child should lead ? My answer to that is no.
If two people decide that they want to take on the responsibility of parenthood, then they must also readily accept that their child will be their own person. It is a parent's responsibility to care and provide for their child till they are of age, and no child owes their parents the right to make major decisions about their life, in exchange for that.
Now, however scathing this post may appear to be in regards to parenthood and particularly my own parents, I want to assure you all that I am not some crazed parent hater. I understand and can empathise with the plight that parents can face. Indeed, putting myself in the position of a parent makes me wholly appreciate the difficulty in giving your child free reign over their lives, with the worry that they could really 'make a mess' of it and end up in serious trouble. Yet, there comes a point when the decisions of your child are no longer yours to make. And even though a child legally becomes an adult at the age of 18, they should be treated with the dignity and respect of one well before that. Their decisions should be respected and acknowledged as their own desires and wishes, not versions of your own (as parents).